Disclaimer: Some or all of the companies listed here may provide us compensation. This is a part of how we maintain our free service for consumers. Compensation, along with hundreds of hours of in-depth research determines the results of our reviews.

Rust Rare Coin is a unique online store founded in 1966. It is a family-owned business with an impressive record of buying and selling rare coins. We offer a wide variety of coins from all over the world, including many that are no longer in circulation.

In addition to its brick-and-mortar store in Chicago, Rust Rare Coins also has an online presence making it easy for potential investors to browse their selection and find the perfect coin for their collection.

Whether you are a seasoned collector or just starting, we are sure to have something for you. We take pride in our extensive selection and commitment to providing excellent customer service.

Before we continue with this review, we had to show you this!

Our #1 recommended precious metals company is currently running a limited time offer where they will match dollar for dollar up to 10% of your order in free silver!

For example, a $50,000 order would get you $5,000 in free silver!

>> Learn More About This Limited Time Offer Here <<

There's a reason this is our #1 recommended precious metals company:

  • Over $1 BILLION in retirement savings protected
  • Over 1,000 5 star reviews
  • Thousands of happy customers
  • A+ BBB rating
  • AAA customer rated
  • 5x Inc 500 winner


Rusty Rare Coin Overview

Rusty Rare Coin

Rust Rare Coin Company produces a variety of rare coins, including some that are very valuable. Here's a look at some of the most valuable types of rare coins produced by Rust Rare Coin Company:

  • Proof Coins: Proof coins are made for collectors and are usually worth more than regular coins. Rust Rare Coin Company has produced several proof coins, including the highly sought-after 1804 dollar.
  • Error Coins: Error coins have mistakes on them, such as misprints or double-struck errors. These coins can be very valuable, especially if they're rare. Rust Rare Coin Company has produced several error coins, including the famous 1955 "double die" penny.
  • Pattern Coins: Pattern coins were made as prototypes for new coins but were never put into circulation. They can be very valuable, especially if they're rare. Rust Rare Coin Company has produced several pattern coins, including the highly sought-after 1804 dollar.
  • Commemorative Coins: Commemorative coins are made to commemorate a special event or person. They can be very valuable, especially if they're rare. Rust Rare Coin Company has produced several commemorative coins, including the highly sought-after 1804 dollar.
  • Gold Coins: Gold coins are always valuable, and Rust Rare Coin Company has produced several over the years. The most valuable gold coin produced by Rust Rare Coin Company is the 1804 dollar.
  • Platinum Coins: Platinum coins minted by Rust Rare Coin Company include the $100 Platinum Eagle and the $100 American Platinum Eagle. These coins contain 1 Troy oz. of .9995 fine platinum. The Platinum Eagles have a diameter of 32.7 mm.
  • Palladium Coins: Palladium coins minted by Rust Rare Coin Company include the $25 American Palladium Eagle and the $50 American Palladium Eagle. These coins contain 1 Troy oz. of .9995 fine palladium. The Palladium Eagles have a diameter of 32.7 mm.
  • Native American Dollars: First minted in 2009, the Native American Dollar is made of 88.5% copper, 6% zinc, 3.5% manganese, and 2% silver. It contains .8592 Troy oz. of pure silver. The coin has a diameter of 26.5 mm, making it smaller than a modern dime.
  • Presidential Dollars: First minted in 2007, the Presidential Dollar is made of 88.5% copper, 6% zinc, 3.5% manganese, and 2% silver. It contains .8592 Troy oz. of pure silver. The coin has a diameter of 26.5 mm, making it smaller than a modern dime.
  • Zinc pennies: These are the most valuable type of rare coins we produce. They are made from a zinc alloy and were first minted in 1982. They are considered very rare and valuable due to their unique composition.
  • Steel pennies: These are other types of rare coins we produce. They are made from a steel alloy and were first minted in 1943. They are also considered to be very rare and valuable due to their unique composition.
  • Bronze pennies: These are the third type of rare coin we produce, which are made from a bronze alloy and were first minted in 1962. They are considered to be rare and valuable due to their unique composition.
Rusty Rare Coin

Pros & Cons of Rusty Rare Coin

Pros:

  • We are a BBB-accredited business with an A+ rating, so you can be confident that you're dealing with a reputable company.
  • We focus on customer service. We believe that our customers should always come first, and we work hard to ensure that they are satisfied with every purchase they make from us.
  • We focus on customer service. We believe that our customers should always come first, and we work hard to ensure that they are satisfied with every purchase they make from us.
  • We take pride in offering our clients the best service possible, which starts with providing accurate and up-to-date information on the rare coin market.
  • We also offer our clients a wide range of services, including appraisal and grading services, so you can be confident you are getting the most out of your investment.
  • We also offer free shipping on all orders and accept payment by credit card, PayPal, or check. We also offer a layaway plan to make purchasing rare coins easy and affordable.
  • We offer a wide variety of rare coins from all over the world. Whether you are looking for an ancient Greek or a modern American coin, we have what you are looking for.
  • We offer a money-back satisfaction guarantee, so you can buy with confidence, knowing that you can return your purchase if you're unhappy with it.

Cons:

  • They may not have the exact coin you are looking for. Although the company has a large inventory, it may not have the specific coin you're hoping to find.
  • Prices can be high: Because Rust Rare Coin Company specializes in rare and valuable coins, their prices can sometimes be higher than what you would find at a more general coin dealer. This is something to keep in mind if you work with a tight budget.
  • You may have to wait for your order: Due to the nature of their business, it can sometimes take longer for orders to be filled. This can be frustrating if you are in a hurry to receive your purchase.
  • Rust Rare Coin Company specializes in older coins, which may not be ideal if you're looking for more modern pieces.
  • Customer service is not the best: There have been many complaints about the customer service of Rust Rare Coin Company. There have been reports of long wait times, unprofessional staff, and not getting calls or emails returned promptly.
  • There is a risk of fraud: As with any online transaction, there is always a risk of fraud when dealing with Rust Rare Coin Company. Be sure to research the company thoroughly before making any purchases.
  • They have been known to sell fake coins: While Rust Rare Coin Company sells genuine coins, there have been reports of them selling fake coins. If you want to purchase rare or valuable coins, do your research to avoid being scammed.
  • Shipping can be slow: Some customers have reported that shipping times can be slow, which can be frustrating if you are in a hurry to receive your purchase.
  • They do not take credit or debit cards: This can be a big inconvenience for customers who do not have cash or checks.
  • There is no online presence: This can make it difficult to research the company and its products before making a purchase.
  • The website is not the most user-friendly; while it provides a lot of information, it can be difficult to navigate.
  • The return policy is not the best: You must send the coins back within 14 days, and they will only refund the purchase price, not the shipping cost.
  • Lack of availability of certain coins: While Rust Rare Coin Company may have a wide selection of coins, they may not always have the specific coin you are looking for in stock. This can be frustrating if you are trying to complete a collection or want a certain coin.

Conclusion

Rust Rare Coin Company is a reliable source of rare and valuable coins. However, their prices can be high, and it can take longer for orders to be filled. There have also been complaints about the customer service. Be sure to research the company thoroughly before making any purchases.

Get Your Free Silver & Learn How To Protect Your Money With Precious Metals

We highly recommend that you at least check out our #1 recommended company's special offer they currently have going on where you can get 10% of your order in FREE silver.

You can also learn how to use your precious metals purchase to get major retirement and tax savings!

>> Get More Information Here <<

Or continue below!