Disclaimer: Some or all of the companies listed here may provide us compensation. This is a part of how we maintain our free service for consumers. Compensation, along with hundreds of hours of in-depth research determines the results of our reviews.

If you live in or near Idaho, and you're searching for the best precious metals provider, you may have heard a few things about Gem State Gold and Silver. Located in Boise, Gem State Gold and Silver is a respected company in the area, but are they the right precious metals buyer and sell for you to work with? 

If you have questions about Gem State Gold and Silver and want to learn more about whether they are the right fit for your needs, then keep reading. We'll share information about the company's history and the products and services they offer. Keep reading; and hopefully all of your questions will be answered.

  • Product: Precious Metals
  • Owner: Marvin and Yvonne Tanner
  • Overall Rating: 3.7/5

Before we continue with this review, we had to show you this!

Our #1 recommended precious metals company is currently running a limited time offer where they will match dollar for dollar up to 10% of your order in free silver!

For example, a $50,000 order would get you $5,000 in free silver!

>> Learn More About This Limited Time Offer Here <<

There's a reason this is our #1 recommended precious metals company:

  • Over $1 BILLION in retirement savings protected
  • Over 1,000 5 star reviews
  • Thousands of happy customers
  • A+ BBB rating
  • AAA customer rated
  • 5x Inc 500 winner

Or, see if Gem State Gold & Silver made our list of the best 5 precious metals investment companies:

>> Our Top Gold Investment Companies For This Year <<

About Gem State Gold and Silver

Gem State Gold and Silver Review

Gem State Gold and Silver is a precious metals buyer, seller, and assayer located in Boise, Idaho. The company has been owned by Marvin and Yvonne Tanner for over 30 years. Since it was started, Gem State Gold and Silver has been providing services to the people of Boise, Idaho and the surrounding areas. In fact, they are one of the largest sellers and buyers of precious metals in the state. 

In addition to selling precious metals, Gem State Gold and Silver also purchases precious metals from individuals looking to sell. Beyond just purchasing coins and bars, they will also purchase old or broken gold and silver jewelry of any karat, or can even melt your unwanted jewelry items into a bar. We'll go into more detail about these services in the sections that follow.

Purchasing Precious Metals

Gem State Gold and Silver has a large bank vault located in Boise. The vault holds a wide assortment of different gold and silver coins and bars. If you are interested in purchasing precious metals, simply reach out to Gem State Gold and Silver. 

They are open by appointment only to provide you with a private and secure experience to view the precious metals you are interested in purchasing. To accommodate the needs of individuals with busy schedules, they accept appointments seven days a week. The website lists the contact information so that you can call, text, or email Gem State Gold and Silver to set up your appointment. 

Selling Your Precious Metals to Gem State Gold and Silver

Gem State Gold and Silver Review

In addition to purchasing precious metals from Gen State Gold and Service, the company may also be interested in buying precious metals from you that you are looking to sell. According to the website, they are among the largest buyer of gold and silver in the state of Idaho. 

If you have any coins or bars that you'd like to sell, just reach out to Gem State Gold and Silver to schedule an appointment. Then, you can bring your precious metals to your storefront location to receive a quote. 

In addition to selling coins and bars that you no longer wish to hold or want to liquidate for needed cash, Gem State Gold and Silver will also purchase your broken or outdated gold or silver jewelry. This presents you with an opportunity to receive cash for something that would otherwise end up in the trash or sit in the bottom of a drawer for the foreseeable future. 

Making a Gold or Silver Bar from Old Jewelry

If you have old or broken jewelry, you could also work with Gem State Gold and Silver to turn it into a bar. They will melt down broken pieces or raw precious metals for you and form it into a gold or silver bar. If you aren't in immediate need for cash, this could be a way to help you increase your precious metals holdings. 

Comprehensive X-Ray Studies

Gem State Gold and Silver is one of the few places in the United States that has an energy dispersant x-ray fluorescent spectrometer. They can use this specialized machine to analyze any object, except for gas. The machine can identify how thick the gold or silver plating on a piece of jewelry is, calculate the ounce per ton for different items, and more. 

Working with Gem State Gold and Silver with this special machine can help you to maximize your earnings and make sure you get the best value for the metals you sell. 


  • Gem State Gold and Silver is located in Boise, Idaho.
  • It was founded by Martin and Yvonne Tanner over 30 years ago.
  • Gem State Gold and Silver has an A+ rating with the BBB.
  • The company has a private location where customers can discreetly buy or sell their precious metals.
  • You can make an appointment with Gem State Gold and silver on any day as long as you call in advance.
  • Gem State Gold and Silver buys and sells precious metals.
  • They will also purchase old broken jewelry made from precious metals.
  • You can bring in old broken jewelry to have it melted down and turned into a bar.
  • Their energy dispersant x-ray fluorescent spectrometer can analyze precious metals to determine the exact plating thickness, ounce per ton ratio, and more.


  • Gem State Gold and Silver is a respected precious metals buyer and seller in Idaho.
  • With their x-ray fluorescent spectrometer, you can bring in objects to be analyzed to determine the ratio of gold they hold.
  • They can melt down old jewelry to create a gold or silver bar.


  • The website is not as professional as many others and doesn't include as much detail.

Final Verdict

If you are local to Boise, Idaho, Gem State Gold and Silver may be a convenient choice when you're looking to buy or sell your precious metals. However, if you aren't local, they may not be the right fit for you because their website doesn't appear to offer online ordering. What do you think? Does Gem State Gold and Silver sound like the right match for you, or will you be continuing on with your search for the best precious metals provider.

Get Your Free Silver & Learn How To Protect Your Money With Precious Metals

We highly recommend that you at least check out our #1 recommended company's special offer they currently have going on where you can get 10% of your order in FREE silver.

You can also learn how to use your precious metals purchase to get major retirement and tax savings!

>> Get More Information Here <<

Or continue below!