Disclaimer: Some or all of the companies listed here may provide us compensation. This is a part of how we maintain our free service for consumers. Compensation, along with hundreds of hours of in-depth research determines the results of our reviews.

American Rarities PA was founded in 1991 and has been a rare coin dealer since, spending over $150 million acquiring rare coins and US paper currency collections. Their coin purchasers are numismatic and notaphily specialists with over a century of combined expertise. They take pleasure in making the best offer the market would allow on all collections they appraise for acquisition.

For almost 25 years, American Rarities has served the collecting public throughout the United States. For more extensive collections, their buyers go anywhere in the United States. American Rarities provides complimentary coin appraisals on all collections they consider for acquisition. Furthermore, they give the collecting public a wide range of rare coin services.

Before we continue with this review, we had to show you this!

Our #1 recommended precious metals company is currently running a limited time offer where they will match dollar for dollar up to 10% of your order in free silver!

For example, a $50,000 order would get you $5,000 in free silver!

>> Learn More About This Limited Time Offer Here <<

There's a reason this is our #1 recommended precious metals company:

  • Over $1 BILLION in retirement savings protected
  • Over 1,000 5 star reviews
  • Thousands of happy customers
  • A+ BBB rating
  • AAA customer rated
  • 5x Inc 500 winner


American Rarities PA

They buy US coins, foreign coins, paper money, and bullion from coin collectors around the country daily. They also buy rare coin collections of all shapes and sizes and provide free assessments on any collections they consider for acquisition.

As skilled coin dealers, their staff works hard to provide the best offer possible on every coin collection they analyze. Unlike other coin dealers, they do not "cherry select" collections; their coin purchasers are interested in both ordinary and mundane coins and the rarest and most esoteric items.

How do American Rarities, PA Determine the Worth of Rare Coin Collections?

American Rarities PA

The first step in receiving an evaluation and offer on your rare coins is to tell them about your collection. It's as simple as sending or texting them an inventory list or images of your coins or just telling them over the phone what you have.

Their coin purchasing specialist will contact you to get further details. Next, the expert will determine coin values, using all available materials to provide an accurate estimate.

They select the best strategy to organize the physical purchase of your coin collection once the initial evaluation is finished. This can be a face-to-face appointment with a rare coin buyer near you or mailing your rare coins to their coin buyer for physical inspection and sale. You will receive the most incredible possible price for your rare coin collection in any situation.

What are Their Ratings?

Their BBB profile shows they have an A Plus rating and have been in business for 25 years. They have eight reviews on BBB with an average rating of 4 out of 5 stars. However, they have a one-star rating on Yelp (one out of five stars). They have one review, so perhaps take it with a grain of salt.

The Benefits and Drawbacks of American Rarities PA


  • The BBB gave it an A+ grade.
  • They have been in operation for 25 years.
  • Their website appears to be user-friendly.


  • If the Yelp review is correct, it seems like you're in for a wild journey.
  • They do not appear to offer bullion or coins to the general public.

Is American Rarities PA a Legitimate Company?

American Rarities does not appear to be a sham. They may not provide you with the price you seek; thus, it is entirely up to you to conduct your research before determining who to deal with and what offer you are willing to accept. You most likely care about "you" more than anybody else, so proceed cautiously. American Rarities appears to be a legitimate firm, but you should conduct your investigation as usual.


No precious metals firm will ever be flawless. Each may bring a unique perspective to the table where one may be a better match for you than the other. They may also perform similar things differently; therefore, it may be a question of preference since every firm is unique. There is no "one size fits all" solution.

Get Your Free Silver & Learn How To Protect Your Money With Precious Metals

We highly recommend that you at least check out our #1 recommended company's special offer they currently have going on where you can get 10% of your order in FREE silver.

You can also learn how to use your precious metals purchase to get major retirement and tax savings!

>> Get More Information Here <<

Or continue below!